Whole Life Insurance Dividend Rate History

By November 29, 2019 January 14th, 2020 Whole Life Dividends
Updated Nov 29th, 2019

Whole Life Insurance Dividend Rate History

Whole life insurance performance is highly dependent on dividend rates. So we wanted to have an updated list of Whole Life Insurance Dividend History.

This table only refers to participating policies. 

Historical Whole Life Dividend Rates 2020

Historical Whole Life Dividend Rates 2020

What is participating policy? 

A participating policy is one that pays dividends to the policy holder. The most competitive participating policies are from mutual companies.

The reason is they do not have stockholders, so the only dividend they pay is to policyholders.

Why is the history of whole life dividends important?

We can take the highest dividend companies from today and pick the best one. However, we prefer to use today’s rates and historical rates because it will give us a better idea of how the dividend will perform in the future.

Even-though the past performance doesn’t indicate future performance.

We took the following Historical Whole Life Table that has incredible data, and updated the numbers:

We will keep updating it, and feel free to contact us, so we add a company. 

Year20202019201820172016201520142013201220112010200920082007
General AmericanNANA4.94.94.94.94.95.255.55.55.55.755.756.05
Guardian5.655.855.855.856.056.056.256.656.956.8577.37.256.75
John HancockNAN/AN/AN/A5.155.35.555.555.555.755.756.256.256.25
MassMutual6.26.46.46.77.17.17.1776.8577.67.97.5
MetLife4.74.74.74.755.15.15.255.55.55.756.256.256.25
New England Financial4.654.654.654.6555555.255.255.255.55.56
New York LifeNA6.06.16.36.26.265.95.86.116.116.146.796.79
Northwestern Mutual5.05.04.955.455.65.65.65.8566.156.57.57.5
Penn Mutual6.16.16.346.346.346.346.346.346.346.346.346.346.346.3
Ohio NationalNA5.45.45.7566666.156.156.46.46.656.65
ForestersNA6.236.236.586.836.656.426.456.095.905.605.606.326.70
 

Whole Life Insurance Dividend Rates for 2020

At the end of the year, most companies start announcing their dividend rates for next year. Here are the whole life dividend rates for 2020 ahead of time. As we become aware of more, we will list them out. 

Forester NA
MassMutual 6.2
Penn Mutual 6.1
New York Life NA
Guardian 5.65
Ohio National NA
Northwestern Mutual 5.0

Whole Life Insurance Dividend Rates for 2019

Here is the full 2019 whole life dividend list from the largest and most important carriers.

MassMutual 6.4
Foresters 6.23
Penn Mutual 6.1
New York Life 6.0
Guardian 5.85
Ohio National 5.4
Northwestern Mutual 5.0

Whole Life Insurance Dividend Rankings for 2018

Here is a quick summary of the dividend rate from some of the largest/best companies that offer whole life insurance. 

Forester 6.58
MassMutual 6.4
Penn Mutual 6.34
New York Life 6.2
Guardian 5.85
Ohio National 5.4
Northwestern Mutual 4.9

Whole Life Insurance Dividend Rankings for 2017

Here are the ranking for 2017. We have all the numbers for all years, but this will make it much easier to read. In the following table, we ranked the companies that are still popular and are still selling whole life insurance products.

In reality, you can see that these are large mutual companies.

MassMutual 6.7
Penn Mutual 6.34
New York Life 6.2
Guardian 5.85
Ohio National 5.75
Northwestern Mutual 5

Whole Life Insurance Dividend Rates Historical Averages

It can be hard to understand all the data, so we created a simpler way for you to look at the information. We have the 10 year and the 15 year averages for the whole life dividends. 

Company Name10 yr average15 Yr Average
General American5.255.51
Guardian6.556.58
John Hancock5.685.89
Manulife6.316.79
Mass Mutual7.077.14
MetLife5.375.65
New England Financial5.105.40
New York Life6.156.32
Northwestern Mutual5.836.29
Penn Mutual6.346.25
Phoenix5.586.03
Sun Life6.316.71
Ohio National6.086.30
Foresters6.256.27

Final Opinion

We used the previous tables, and in addition we used the dividend analysis found at InsuranceProBlog to add more validation to our results (their report).

Our rating for current whole life dividend strength:

#1 MassMutual

MassMutual has a current dividend of 6.2%, which ranks #1 in 2020. Also, we ran a historical analysis and found:

  • 15 year average of 7.14% which also ranks in #1
  • Ten year average of 7.07% which also ranks in #1

That is why it is our best pick for the top whole life insurance dividend.

#2 Foresters

Foresters always announce their dividend rate for the previous year, unlike other companies. So they are still one year back. We rank the “new” kid in town as #2 in terms of dividend strength. At 6.23%, Foresters has the second-highest dividend for 2019 and is positioned to have a good outlook in 2020.

#3 Penn Mutual

Penn Mutual has a current dividend of 6.1%, which ranks #2 for 2020. Also, Penn has always had a very stable dividend, even in a decreasing interest rate environment. They use direct recognition on the whole life contracts.

Do you have a dividend-paying whole life that you would like us to add? 

The dividend rate is not everything, so to learn a little bit more about whole life insurance you should read:

Whole Life Insurance For Dummies

Overfunding Whole Life Insurance

How Much Does Whole Life Cost?

Want To See How Dividends Affect Cash Value?

Get The Highest Dividends & Best Whole Life Quotes

Join the discussion 5 Comments

  • Glenn says:

    What makes me laugh about this is that Dividends do NOT define the actual policy performance. Why don’t you pull a Blease Report and see who is on top when it comes to actual Cash Value Return. Many companies show the Dividend before expenses but if we are chasing the IRR and actual Cash Value then there is only one company that continues to exceed all other by a minimum of 35%. I’ll let your team not trick the consumer into just looking at the dividend rate.

    • WholeLifeExpert says:

      Hi Glenn,
      We stand by our analysis. The last Blease Report that we are aware of is in 2013. Please see the data here Blease Report 2013
      We are working on developing our own in for 2018. Who do you believe has the best dividend?

      • Patrick says:

        What Glenn says is accurate. Focusing on the dividend rate without accounting for the costs is misleading at best.

        • WholeLifeExpert says:

          Thank you for your input. There is nothing misleading about stating historical facts. This is an article on whole life dividend history, and we wanted to highlight dividends. It isn’t intended as a guide to pick the best whole life. However, dividend performance affects whole life performance, so we wanted to give an accurate historical analysis. Every consumer should still compare actual performance, but remember that current illustrations are based on current dividends. Some companies will have a higher dividend than today, and some will have a lower dividend.

  • Richard says:

    The Blease Report is a bit of a deceiving comparison in that it contains some very important footnotes. The premiums across the comparison are very different giving the lead horse (not so coincidentally, the carrier that funded the analysis) a much higher premium and thus more emphasis on cash value. If you increased the premium on each contract to match by using paid up additions, you’d see a much different IRR on cash value that summarized in the report… It also cherry picked the starting year. Using “best class available” in a year where the lead horse (again the carrier that funded the 3rd party, Blease) was the only carrier to offer preferred classes vs. standard non-tobacco being best available for all others until the following years where preferred tiers were rolled out. Statistical analysis can be 100% accurate, but be very misleading. Follow the money and you’ll see a major conflict of interest with one carrier pointing to Blease as an independent third party while being the sole source of revenue for Blease.

Leave a Reply